No Tryouts. No Cuts. No Competition.

May 26th, 2008, 9 Comments »

I seem to be obsessing about the copy writing on packaging lately. I’m not sure why, but bear with me–I’m sure this too, shall pass.

This photo shows a box of tasty Girl Guide (or should that be ‘Girl Guides’?) cookies that I recently bought. On the box, they prominently feature text that reads “No tryouts. No cuts. No competition. It’s the great greatest team she’ll ever join.”:

No Tryouts. No Cuts. No Competition.

This text reflects an ongoing trend (I wrote about it previously) toward reducing or eliminating competition among children. I often hear members of Generation Y–the early beneficiaries of this trend–characterized as being superb collaborators and team members, but under-motivated in the face of competition.

Of course, these are just enormous generalizations that make demographers and marketers happy, but I could see a correlation there. I really know nothing about child development and psychology, so I just point out this Girl Guide box as a sign o’ the times.

On a vaguely related topic, I’ve been enjoying reading this discussion of parenthood on Jen’s blog.

9 Comments »

Has Competition Disappeared From Kids’ Sports?

September 14th, 2007, 8 Comments »

Caterina wrote a nice little essay about her failed soccer career, and ended with this charming anecdote:

They don’t let little kids compete these days, because it might ruin their self esteem. I see it all the time. A friend of mine at work said her 8 year old son played soccer, and one day he came home from playing and she asked him how many goals he’d scored. “There are no goals,” he said.

I don’t have much exposure to children’s sports. Parents, is this anti-competition streak common these days?

8 Comments »